Difference between revisions of "Fed Up!"

From Alfino
Jump to navigationJump to search
m
Line 9: Line 9:
 
==Notes for "Fed Up!"==
 
==Notes for "Fed Up!"==
  
:*Challenging the Diet/Exercise Paradigm -- "energy balance" is a false theory because calories have different effects depending upon the food.
+
:*News of Obesity and related health epidemic. 
 +
 
 +
:*Narrative is broadly suscipious that our approach to the epidemic is
 +
 
 +
:*Brady Kluge age 15 --- web cam introduction.  4min.  Family food culture. 
 +
 
 +
:*Challenging the Diet/Exercise Paradigm -- "energy balance" (calories in / calories out) is a limited theory because calories have different effects depending upon the food.  Eat less/exercise more.  Origin of theory in Dr. Jean Mayer.  Leads to Jane Fonda....  Retro exercise footage....  Also, amount of exercise needed wouldn't fit in a day....
 +
 
 +
:*Maggie Valentine - 12 yr old - note tour of food products in the house -- beliefs about health food: Triscut low fat and industrial cereals....  Gary Taubes  12:43
 +
 
 +
:*Why energy balance in limited:  Example of almonds/soda -- role of fiber in moderating blood sugar rise.  14:00 mins.  Coca cola ad espousing energy balance theory.
 +
 
 +
:*Marion Nestle. 14:45.  Big star in nutrition policy.  Coca Cola funding scandal.  Dr. David Allison -- Big Sugar scientist interviewed.  Yikes.....
  
 
:*Big Sugar Funding Scandals - Nestle describes an early version of this, but there was a more recent scandal involving many "professors" paid collectively $50 million.  [https://www.nytimes.com/2016/09/13/well/eat/how-the-sugar-industry-shifted-blame-to-fat.html] [https://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2015/08/09/coca-cola-funds-scientists-who-shift-blame-for-obesity-away-from-bad-diets/]
 
:*Big Sugar Funding Scandals - Nestle describes an early version of this, but there was a more recent scandal involving many "professors" paid collectively $50 million.  [https://www.nytimes.com/2016/09/13/well/eat/how-the-sugar-industry-shifted-blame-to-fat.html] [https://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2015/08/09/coca-cola-funds-scientists-who-shift-blame-for-obesity-away-from-bad-diets/]
  
:*1977 Dietary Guidelines Story
+
:*Wesley Randall.  age 13.  Note foods in the family. Lean hot pockets....  Industrial cereals....  Cheap calories (fast food "value" meals).  20:45: meal comparions.  Not necessarily true that health meals are unaffordable.  Doctor visit...  23: Clinton admits "we missed it" 
 +
 
 +
:*1977 Dietary Guidelines Story 24:45min  (We'll get this story a couple of times.)  McGovern committee guidelines trigger backlash....
 
::*can't say eat less, can't target any foods directly.  
 
::*can't say eat less, can't target any foods directly.  
::*Low fat movement correlates with increase in sugar in industrial food.  600,000 food products 80% with added sugar
+
::*Low fat movement correlates with increase in sugar in industrial food.  600,000 food products 80% with added sugar.  '77 to 2000 double intake of sugar.  (History of sugar is fascinating.) 
::*Glycemic response.  Insulin a fat storage hormone.  Also loss of neural signal that you are "full"
+
 
 +
::*Glycemic response.  27:45 Insulin a fat storage hormone.  Also loss of neural signal that you are "full" Note product comparison on sugar. 
 +
 
 +
:*HFCS  (High fructose corn syrup) - industrial fruit juice may be about as calorie dense as Coke.  (Also industrial carb products.)  Sugar substitutes can trigger glycemic response as well.  32:00 tracking the foods that the kids in the doc are eating. 
 +
 
 +
:*Joe Lopez.  33:30.  Note personal and family self-understanding of problem.
 +
 
 +
::*David Kessler -- food addiction theory - ubiquity of sugar in the culture and media.
  
:*HFCS - fruit juice as good as Coke. 
 
::*David Kessler -- food addiction theory - ubiquity of sugar in the culture and media
 
 
::*WHO TRS 916 - study adocates no more than 10% of calories from sugar.  US heavy handed response, threats withold funding.  Industry wanted 25%.  Result: No agreed level on US product nutrition panels.
 
::*WHO TRS 916 - study adocates no more than 10% of calories from sugar.  US heavy handed response, threats withold funding.  Industry wanted 25%.  Result: No agreed level on US product nutrition panels.
  
Line 34: Line 53:
 
:*Tobacco / Food Industry Analogy Story  -- soda is the cigarette of the 21st century.
 
:*Tobacco / Food Industry Analogy Story  -- soda is the cigarette of the 21st century.
  
:*Real Food / Fake Food
+
:*Real Food / Fake Food - Back to defining food.
 
 
 
 
:STUDENT NOTES
 
 
 
:*Facts
 
::*Sugar is 8 times more addictive than cocaine
 
::*Nutrition facts does not provide the percent of sugar that contributes to your daily intake of sugar
 
::*Dailey intake of sugar had doubled since 1977
 
::*In 1980 there were 0 cases of type II diabetes in children, in 2010 is was 57,638
 
::*Gym and oversight people in America doubled at the same time
 
::*Kids by 2-3 years old can start recognizing brands
 
::*Weight lose surgeries have increase 5 fold in the past few years
 
 
 
:*Conclusions
 
::*Private profit and interests outweighs public health
 
::*Soda is the cigarette industry of the 21st century
 
::*"Eat less. Exercise more." will not cure obesity
 

Revision as of 19:03, 23 January 2018

Return to Philosophy of Food

1. Facts that you are surprised by, think important, or are suspicious of.;

2. Questions raised by the movie;

3. Claims or thesis that the movie's documentary evidence seems to support.

Notes for "Fed Up!"

  • News of Obesity and related health epidemic.
  • Narrative is broadly suscipious that our approach to the epidemic is
  • Brady Kluge age 15 --- web cam introduction. 4min. Family food culture.
  • Challenging the Diet/Exercise Paradigm -- "energy balance" (calories in / calories out) is a limited theory because calories have different effects depending upon the food. Eat less/exercise more. Origin of theory in Dr. Jean Mayer. Leads to Jane Fonda.... Retro exercise footage.... Also, amount of exercise needed wouldn't fit in a day....
  • Maggie Valentine - 12 yr old - note tour of food products in the house -- beliefs about health food: Triscut low fat and industrial cereals.... Gary Taubes 12:43
  • Why energy balance in limited: Example of almonds/soda -- role of fiber in moderating blood sugar rise. 14:00 mins. Coca cola ad espousing energy balance theory.
  • Marion Nestle. 14:45. Big star in nutrition policy. Coca Cola funding scandal. Dr. David Allison -- Big Sugar scientist interviewed. Yikes.....
  • Big Sugar Funding Scandals - Nestle describes an early version of this, but there was a more recent scandal involving many "professors" paid collectively $50 million. [1] [2]
  • Wesley Randall. age 13. Note foods in the family. Lean hot pockets.... Industrial cereals.... Cheap calories (fast food "value" meals). 20:45: meal comparions. Not necessarily true that health meals are unaffordable. Doctor visit... 23: Clinton admits "we missed it"
  • 1977 Dietary Guidelines Story 24:45min (We'll get this story a couple of times.) McGovern committee guidelines trigger backlash....
  • can't say eat less, can't target any foods directly.
  • Low fat movement correlates with increase in sugar in industrial food. 600,000 food products 80% with added sugar. '77 to 2000 double intake of sugar. (History of sugar is fascinating.)
  • Glycemic response. 27:45 Insulin a fat storage hormone. Also loss of neural signal that you are "full" Note product comparison on sugar.
  • HFCS (High fructose corn syrup) - industrial fruit juice may be about as calorie dense as Coke. (Also industrial carb products.) Sugar substitutes can trigger glycemic response as well. 32:00 tracking the foods that the kids in the doc are eating.
  • Joe Lopez. 33:30. Note personal and family self-understanding of problem.
  • David Kessler -- food addiction theory - ubiquity of sugar in the culture and media.
  • WHO TRS 916 - study adocates no more than 10% of calories from sugar. US heavy handed response, threats withold funding. Industry wanted 25%. Result: No agreed level on US product nutrition panels.
  • Obama "Let's Move Campaign" -- coopted by industry into an exercise program. Can't say processed food is a big part of the problem.
  • Dept of Ag conflict of interest: promoting production and promoting good diets.
  • The Great Cheese Story (50:26)
  • School Lunches Story -- After decline of Fed funding for school lunch program, most schools make contracts with fast food providers. Pizza becomes a vegetable!
  • Tofi -- Thin people can be "obese"
  • Tobacco / Food Industry Analogy Story -- soda is the cigarette of the 21st century.
  • Real Food / Fake Food - Back to defining food.