Difference between revisions of "Comment Key for 1st graded reconstruction"

From Alfino
Jump to navigationJump to search
 
Line 1: Line 1:
 
==Numbered Comments==
 
==Numbered Comments==
  
1.  How many rationales did you find?
+
# How many rationales did you find?
2.  Make it clear that this is an explanation of the data in the Lancet study.
+
# Make it clear that this is an explanation of the data in the Lancet study.
3.  You should put this in the context of a "response to a counter argument".
+
# You should put this in the context of a "response to a counter argument".
4.  I considered following this passage where Noah clarifies or interprets McCaughey's argument, but after checking her article, I decided it was no big deal.  Noah really is just clarifying her conclusion.
+
# I considered following this passage where Noah clarifies or interprets McCaughey's argument, but after checking her article, I decided it was no big deal.  Noah really is just clarifying her conclusion.

Revision as of 19:27, 14 October 2007

Numbered Comments

  1. How many rationales did you find?
  2. Make it clear that this is an explanation of the data in the Lancet study.
  3. You should put this in the context of a "response to a counter argument".
  4. I considered following this passage where Noah clarifies or interprets McCaughey's argument, but after checking her article, I decided it was no big deal. Noah really is just clarifying her conclusion.