Difference between revisions of "MAR 22"

From Alfino
Jump to navigationJump to search
(Created page with "==17: MAR 22== ===Assigned=== :*SW3: Assessing claims about determinism and free will. :*Dennett, Daniel. Chapter 5: "Where Does all the Design Come From?" Freedom Evolves....")
 
 
(One intermediate revision by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
==17: MAR 22==
+
==16. MAR 22==
  
===Assigned===
+
===Assigned Work (Heavy Reading Day)===
  
:*SW3: Assessing claims about determinism and free will.
+
:*Rachel Lauden, ''Cuisine and Empire'' Introduction and Chapter 6, "Christian Cuisine"
:*Dennett, Daniel. Chapter 5: "Where Does all the Design Come From?" Freedom Evolves. (300) (141-170)
+
:*Watch Mother Noella segment from Pollan's "Cooked" series (video file in Shared folder)
  
===Doing Justice to the Prime Mammal Fallacy===
+
===In-Class===
  
:*The PM fallacy is generated by imposing essentialist (binary, all or nothing, impervious to time) conditions for identity onto a naturalistic process.  
+
:*Minor point from Grocery store discussion -- Following the "logic of the grocery store", what do you think the next big change in food retail is? 
:*SFAs are "prime mammals" in the sense that they are an essential characterization of a kind of event that allows for self-makingThey are also "regress-stoppers" 127. What if self-making (later design) occurs incrementally from ordinary events?  (In other words, there is no prime mammal, but there are mammals.)
+
:*What is your culinary cosmos?  (Notes from C1 of Lauden.) [https://wiki.gonzaga.edu/alfino/index.php/Philosophy_of_Food_Fall_2020_Class_Notes_and_Reading_Schedule#Lauden.2C_Rachel.2C_.22Intro.22_and_C1.2C_.22Mastering_Grain_Cookery.22]
 +
:*Context for Christian cuisine: Biblical vegetarianismThe three plates of the Judaic food convenant. [https://wiki.gonzaga.edu/alfino/index.php/Philosophy_of_Food_Fall_2018_Class_Notes#Soler.2C_Jean._.22The_Semiotics_of_Food_in_the_Bible.22]
 +
:*Rachel Lauden, ''Cuisine and Empire'' Introduction and Chapter 1, "Mastering Grain Cookery, 20,000 to 300 bce", p. 1-55  (54)[https://wiki.gonzaga.edu/alfino/index.php/Philosophy_of_Food_Fall_2020_Class_Notes_and_Reading_Schedule#Lauden.2C_Rachel.2C_.22Intro.22_and_C1.2C_.22Mastering_Grain_Cookery.22]
 +
:*Recent example of study of "foodways" Iyer, ''On the Curry Trail'' [https://www.amazon.com/Curry-Trail-Chasing-Flavor-Seduced-ebook/dp/B09Z7QSQYN?asin=B0B5L3FF76&revisionId=fc642ca8&format=1&depth=1]
  
:*It generalizes a bit. Used in regresses.  Conflicts between essentialist thinking about naturalist thinking in general.
+
===Mother Noella Cheese Segment from "Cooked"===
  
:*In the context of our course research project, you could say the "prime mammal" is broadly the search for special moment in human action, or condition of our existence, that guarantees our freedom. It seems like "something special" (FW) can only come from "something special".   But natural processes show us that this isn't the typical caseMind from matter, design from (pseudo)randomness.
+
:*Story Mother Noella and the appreciation of creation through cheese. The bacteria come from the earth, from death, and hold the promise of nourishing life!  A good example of culinary cosmos thinking.
 +
:*Story of the wooden cheese vat. Background on dangers of pre-industrial milk and cheese processing. She switches to steel barrel and gets ecoli bacteria.  Experiment.  ''Lactobacillus'' in the wood digest lactose in milk, turns to lactic acid which kills the ''ecoli'' bacteria.  Health inspectors relent.
 +
:*Loss with "blank slate" processing.  Less diversity of bacteria, less diversity of flavor.
 +
:*[US limits importation of soft cheeses, like soft Percorino.]
 +
:*US approach - lowest quality milk goes into industrial cheese making.
 +
:*Handling of cheese during fermentation determines flavor profiles and texture. "Feet of God"
 +
:*Mother Noella at 17:30. Death and the promise of lifeResurrection.
 +
:*Connection between cheese ecology and other ecologies like fields to forests.  
 +
:*War and peace on the cheese rind!
  
===Yes, but...?  Models of determinism===
+
===Rachel Lauden, ''Cuisine and Empire'' Introduction and Chapter 6, "Christian Cuisine"===
  
:*LaPlace's "Newtonian" demon may not be the right image for use to use in the comparisonThe challenge is not to repeat, by other means, the intuition that is being challenged.  
+
:*'''100-400 c.e.''' --
 +
::*Early Christian "communions" were simple communal meals, often in homes. Not unique to small sects.  Separation of food rituals from Romans - don't eat meat sacrificed to Rome. 
 +
::*Bread as metaphor for Christian community (read p. 168). 
 +
::*Separation from Judaic food rituals - blood not prohibited, pork ok.  Focus on humble low meat cuisines.  Meat as luxury. Avoid alcohol and sweets.  Fasts on Wednesday and Friday.  Ascetic communities tried raw food diets.  Cooking thought to be connected to passionsEarly Christian take on some elements of Stoic thought, also about food.
 +
::*Garum, a fish sauce prized in Roman times, prohibited as it was thought to change cold and wet humors of fish to hot and dry, stimulating passions.
  
:*Can a deterministic universe have "open futures"?
+
:*'''350 - 1450 c.e.''' --
 +
::*Constantine's toleration of Christianity in 313. Shift to Constantinople and Byzantine Church as Western Empire falls apart.  Christianity becomes official religion of Eastern empire.  Byzantine court cuisine closer to Hellenistic cuisine of Eastern empire. 
 +
::*Laws ending sacrifice.
 +
::*No meat or dairy on half the days of the year.  Influence of Galen's "Humoral eating theory"  
 +
::*Expansion of Christianity into slavic lands.  Interesting note on apparent "summit" in Kiev
  
:*I will report back to you on this.
+
:*'''1100-1500 c.e.''' --
 +
::*Increase in wealth in Europe led to pan-European Catholic high cuisine. Nobility of Europe increasing an intermarried network.  Nobles travelled with cooks and cookbooks.  Catholic monastic orders like Cistercians operated across Europe, maintained food and culinary traditions of Catholic cuisine. 
 +
::*Theory of Christian culinary cosmos developed as reconquest of Arab domination of Europe led to recovery of Galen and theory of humoral eating.  Also, Islamic cuisine influences: sugar, marzipan, almonds, eggplant (caponata), oranges "syrup," "sherbert," "candy" have arabic derivations.  Disgression on the famous "La Pasticceria Maria Grammatico, Erice, Sicily" [https://www.italymagazine.com/featured-story/story-maria-grammatico-and-her-famous-pasticceria-sicily]
 +
::*Odd feature of high Catholic cuisine - use of disguise and fantasy.  Sieves molds to shape foods into other shapes Read at 179.  Development of sauces using blood distinguished Catholic cuisine from islamic and jewish.  Meanwhile, humble cuisines varied by region and available grains, meats from small animals and birds more than cows and pigs. 
 +
::*Technology - Promoted also by monasteries, mills became more prevalent.  Big change in household food labor equation: An hour on the "rotary quern" a day for a family of five.  Salted and dried fish (cod) come in from the north.  (Still common in European food stores, not so much American.) [https://www.google.com/search?q=rotary+quern+images&rlz=1C1GCEA_enUS860US860&oq=rotary+quern+images&aqs=chrome..69i57.3473j0j7&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8 Rotary Quern images]
  
===Dennett, Daniel. Chapter 5: "Where Does all the Design Come From?" Freedom Evolves===
+
:*'''1450-1650 c.e.''' -- Global Expansion of Catholic Cuisine, esp of Iberian Peninsula.
 +
::*[Side note on Alfred Crosby, ''The Columbian Exchange'' [https://www.amazon.com/Columbian-Exchange-Biological-Consequences-Anniversary/dp/0275980928/ref=sr_1_1?keywords=the+columbian+exchange&qid=1647884833&sprefix=Th+columbian+exc%2Caps%2C230&sr=8-1]]
 +
::*Spanish and Portuguese exploration and conquest: Cuba, Mexico, Aztecs, Phillipines.  Jesuits to the East: Goa, China, Japan.
 +
::*Early global food industries run by Jesuits and order of nuns.  Jesuits: sugar, cacao, and mate' from Americas.  Nuns operated plantations in Peru, Mexico, Manilla, Macao, Guatemala, ...
 +
::*Jesuits operated major cacao plantations in Guatemala and the Amazon, shipping to their operations in Spain, Italy, and S.E. Asia. Played a major role in the technology transfer of chocolate making to Europe. 
 +
::*European encounter with first peoples and religions of Americas sharpened differences of culinary cosmos. Some human sacrifice, unfamiliar foods: insects, bats, spikers, worms...
 +
::*Catholics in Asia - Jesuits in Goa, India.  More exchange, intermarriage, curries and sauces,
 +
::*Importance of technology: Story of Maize processing. Mesoamericans understood how to treat maize with alkali (nixtamalization).  Brings out vitamins like B3.  Lack of this technology in southern Italy and the American south led to pellagra outbreaks (lack of B3).
  
:*Design in the Boston Symphony Orchestra. 
+
:*'''1650 and beyond'''  
 
+
::*Emergence of Modern cuisines as European nobility decline, Protestantism changes view of culinary cosmosModern cuisine emerges in growth of capitalism and secular powerNational cuisines emerge with nation states.
::*Darwinian strategy: go back in time and look for the emergence of design that supports freedom. 
 
::*144: Eukaryotic revolution - symbiosis (recall the artificial life model) .  The design came from outside (maybe like culture).
 
::*146: step to multicellular life required alot of biological machinery.  Who paid for all that R&D? A billion years of prokayotic life. 
 
 
 
:*'''The Prisoner's Dilemma'''
 
::*Cooperation in Biology needs explaining. 
 
::*PD: can be generalized for any cooperative events with similar pay off relationships.  ESS's
 
 
 
:*'''E Pluribus Unum?'''
 
::*How do we explain "cellular group solidarity"? 
 
::*151: reintroduces physical level, design level, intentional stance.  Some of my cells (somatic) are in a "dead end", no branching possibilities.  But germ line cells (related to reproduction) do.  Differential reproduction. 
 
::*Mitosis vs. Meiosis -- 153.  Argues that the blindness of meiosis undercuts selfish gene strategies.  Selection of a genome for reproduction borrows randomly from paternal and maternal lines.  Sort of like Rawls' "veil of ignorance".  Update:  154 about "intergenomic conflict" (example from Sapolsky).  Point for Dennett: You need the intentional stance to express even the rules governing gene-conflicts.  metaphor of "parliment"
 
 
 
::::*Notes from Sapolsky:
 
:::::*Parent-Offspring Conflict  -- conflict based on lack of complete gene sharing bt parent and offspring. weaning conflict.  other biological conflicts between fetus and mother. slightly diff evo agendas. 
 
:::::*Intersexual Genetic Conflict -- In species with low paternal investment, a father's interest might be with the child and against the mother.  "imprinted genes" part of the mechanism for intersexual conflict.  If they come from Dad, it favours more nutrition for the kid. Tournament species have more imprinted genes than pairbonding (as you would expect).
 
 
 
::*Comparison of evolutionary R&D and conscious human R&D (which includes the PD): both involve strategic moves, avoidance, retaliation, choice, and risk.
 
::*Compared to our somatic cells (which are ballistic missiles), at the organism level, we are "guided missiles".  By definition, organisms have a working solution to the problem of cooperation.   
 
 
 
:*'''Digression: The Threat of Genetic Determinism'''
 
::*We are not determined by our genes.  Eyeglasses. Medicine. But somewhat.
 
::*Environment also determines a lot.  Whether you know a language, for example.  [Recall neuroplasticity - compulsive liars]
 
::*Importance of Chance -- description of neuron formation. 
 
::*159: Nature/nurture discussion recalls inside/outside issue in Kane's view of practical reason.  In both cases, we have limited control over the future.  (Freedom isn't just an "internal" condition.)
 
::*Focus on "what we can change" whether the world is deterministic or not. 
 
::*Recalls Diamond's ''Guns, germs, and steel'' - importance of environment"Knowledge of causation is the friend of freedom."
 
 
 
:*'''Degrees of Freedom and the Search for Truth'''
 
::*Even a switch has some "degree of freedom" .  Compare to a brain. 
 
::*Is learning worth the trade offs?  Depends. Tapeworms don't seem to need it.  We spend a good 15-25% of our lives in formal education. 
 
::*Freedom of birds, primates and "false belief" - Ends with idea that culture is a big source of human freedom.
 

Latest revision as of 18:50, 22 March 2023

16. MAR 22

Assigned Work (Heavy Reading Day)

  • Rachel Lauden, Cuisine and Empire Introduction and Chapter 6, "Christian Cuisine"
  • Watch Mother Noella segment from Pollan's "Cooked" series (video file in Shared folder)

In-Class

  • Minor point from Grocery store discussion -- Following the "logic of the grocery store", what do you think the next big change in food retail is?
  • What is your culinary cosmos? (Notes from C1 of Lauden.) [1]
  • Context for Christian cuisine: Biblical vegetarianism. The three plates of the Judaic food convenant. [2]
  • Rachel Lauden, Cuisine and Empire Introduction and Chapter 1, "Mastering Grain Cookery, 20,000 to 300 bce", p. 1-55 (54)[3]
  • Recent example of study of "foodways" Iyer, On the Curry Trail [4]

Mother Noella Cheese Segment from "Cooked"

  • Story Mother Noella and the appreciation of creation through cheese. The bacteria come from the earth, from death, and hold the promise of nourishing life! A good example of culinary cosmos thinking.
  • Story of the wooden cheese vat. Background on dangers of pre-industrial milk and cheese processing. She switches to steel barrel and gets ecoli bacteria. Experiment. Lactobacillus in the wood digest lactose in milk, turns to lactic acid which kills the ecoli bacteria. Health inspectors relent.
  • Loss with "blank slate" processing. Less diversity of bacteria, less diversity of flavor.
  • [US limits importation of soft cheeses, like soft Percorino.]
  • US approach - lowest quality milk goes into industrial cheese making.
  • Handling of cheese during fermentation determines flavor profiles and texture. "Feet of God"
  • Mother Noella at 17:30. Death and the promise of life. Resurrection.
  • Connection between cheese ecology and other ecologies like fields to forests.
  • War and peace on the cheese rind!

Rachel Lauden, Cuisine and Empire Introduction and Chapter 6, "Christian Cuisine"

  • 100-400 c.e. --
  • Early Christian "communions" were simple communal meals, often in homes. Not unique to small sects. Separation of food rituals from Romans - don't eat meat sacrificed to Rome.
  • Bread as metaphor for Christian community (read p. 168).
  • Separation from Judaic food rituals - blood not prohibited, pork ok. Focus on humble low meat cuisines. Meat as luxury. Avoid alcohol and sweets. Fasts on Wednesday and Friday. Ascetic communities tried raw food diets. Cooking thought to be connected to passions. Early Christian take on some elements of Stoic thought, also about food.
  • Garum, a fish sauce prized in Roman times, prohibited as it was thought to change cold and wet humors of fish to hot and dry, stimulating passions.
  • 350 - 1450 c.e. --
  • Constantine's toleration of Christianity in 313. Shift to Constantinople and Byzantine Church as Western Empire falls apart. Christianity becomes official religion of Eastern empire. Byzantine court cuisine closer to Hellenistic cuisine of Eastern empire.
  • Laws ending sacrifice.
  • No meat or dairy on half the days of the year. Influence of Galen's "Humoral eating theory"
  • Expansion of Christianity into slavic lands. Interesting note on apparent "summit" in Kiev
  • 1100-1500 c.e. --
  • Increase in wealth in Europe led to pan-European Catholic high cuisine. Nobility of Europe increasing an intermarried network. Nobles travelled with cooks and cookbooks. Catholic monastic orders like Cistercians operated across Europe, maintained food and culinary traditions of Catholic cuisine.
  • Theory of Christian culinary cosmos developed as reconquest of Arab domination of Europe led to recovery of Galen and theory of humoral eating. Also, Islamic cuisine influences: sugar, marzipan, almonds, eggplant (caponata), oranges "syrup," "sherbert," "candy" have arabic derivations. Disgression on the famous "La Pasticceria Maria Grammatico, Erice, Sicily" [5]
  • Odd feature of high Catholic cuisine - use of disguise and fantasy. Sieves molds to shape foods into other shapes Read at 179. Development of sauces using blood distinguished Catholic cuisine from islamic and jewish. Meanwhile, humble cuisines varied by region and available grains, meats from small animals and birds more than cows and pigs.
  • Technology - Promoted also by monasteries, mills became more prevalent. Big change in household food labor equation: An hour on the "rotary quern" a day for a family of five. Salted and dried fish (cod) come in from the north. (Still common in European food stores, not so much American.) Rotary Quern images
  • 1450-1650 c.e. -- Global Expansion of Catholic Cuisine, esp of Iberian Peninsula.
  • [Side note on Alfred Crosby, The Columbian Exchange [6]]
  • Spanish and Portuguese exploration and conquest: Cuba, Mexico, Aztecs, Phillipines. Jesuits to the East: Goa, China, Japan.
  • Early global food industries run by Jesuits and order of nuns. Jesuits: sugar, cacao, and mate' from Americas. Nuns operated plantations in Peru, Mexico, Manilla, Macao, Guatemala, ...
  • Jesuits operated major cacao plantations in Guatemala and the Amazon, shipping to their operations in Spain, Italy, and S.E. Asia. Played a major role in the technology transfer of chocolate making to Europe.
  • European encounter with first peoples and religions of Americas sharpened differences of culinary cosmos. Some human sacrifice, unfamiliar foods: insects, bats, spikers, worms...
  • Catholics in Asia - Jesuits in Goa, India. More exchange, intermarriage, curries and sauces,
  • Importance of technology: Story of Maize processing. Mesoamericans understood how to treat maize with alkali (nixtamalization). Brings out vitamins like B3. Lack of this technology in southern Italy and the American south led to pellagra outbreaks (lack of B3).
  • 1650 and beyond
  • Emergence of Modern cuisines as European nobility decline, Protestantism changes view of culinary cosmos. Modern cuisine emerges in growth of capitalism and secular power. National cuisines emerge with nation states.