Difference between revisions of "FEB 10"

From Alfino
Jump to navigationJump to search
m
m
 
Line 1: Line 1:
==10: FEB 10==
+
==7. FEB 10==
  
===Assigned===
+
===Assigned Work===
  
:*Hibbing, Ch 6, Different Slates (26)
+
:*Nix, Stacy. Chapter 4: "Proteins" Williams' Basic Nutrition and Diet Therapy (pp. 47-63).
:*[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lzPbUUPutnk Libertarianism in Six Minutes]
+
:*Shepard, Gordon, C7 "Images of Smell: An "Aha" Moment" (66-76; 10)
:*[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Libertarianism Libertarianism wiki] See for historical detail.
+
:*Fill out [https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSfIR4TuYZECqTbeC5M3ys5B2I1qN4kw3cIKbOB8EQj9OObCOA/viewform?usp=sf_link Proteins Worksheet] (Points)
  
===In-class content===
+
===In-class===
  
:*Libertarianism as a moral and political theory
+
:*Energy density v. Nutrient density. 
  
===Libertarianism as a moral and political theory===
+
===Nix, "Proteins"===
  
:*'''Libertarianism in Six Minutes''' (notes)
+
:*'''Nature of'''
  
::*Historical look: '''Libertarianism comes out of radical emancipatory politics.'''
+
::*20 amino acids, 9 essential; proteins are polypeptides -- chains of amino acids 100s of links long.  Proteins exist in specific forms in foods (ex. casein is milk protein) and are broken down by us into amino acids and resembled as protein in metabolism. 
:::*17th century resistance to oppressive conditions. “Rent seekers”. Payne.
+
::*Classes of amino acids: indispensable (9), dispensable (5), and conditionally indispensable (6).  
:::*Similar to socialism and capitalism, a view about what is fair.   
+
::*Conditionally dispensable: Example: If low on Mthionine(essential), then you need cysteine (cond. indis.) from diet.
:::*"Libertarianism originated as a form of left-wing politics such as anti-authoritarian and anti-state socialists like anarchists,[6] especially social anarchists,[7] but more generally libertarian communists/Marxists and libertarian socialists." (from wiki).  
+
::*About 16% nitrogen; protein is a primary source of nitrogen in diet.   
 +
::*Catabolism and Anabolism: Metabolic process of breaking down tissue and building it up.
 +
::*Nitrogen Balance is shown when excretion of urinary nitrogen occurs as by product of protein metabolism (ratio of 1 g of urinary nitrogen to 6.25 g of protein).  Negative nitrogen balance can be a symptom of protein deficiency.  Kwashiorkor. 
 +
::*Tissue proteins, plasma proteins, and dietary protein. You dietary protein is contributing to a much larger and complex protein manufacture and delivery service.
  
::*US libertarianism closer to free market capitalism vs. European, which is more socialist.  (Note: Political ideas can take multiple forms in relation to conservative/liberal.)
+
:*'''Functions of Protein Metabolism'''
:::*''Assumption of natural harmony among productive people'' with liberty of contract.  Laws limited to protection and protection of natural rights. (Non-aggressive principle).  No regulation of market.  Low social spending - people are responsible for themselves and their families.  Taxes are presumed to be coercive and confiscatory. 
 
:::*Conservative libertarian theorist, Robert Nozick, ''Anarchy, State, and Utopia'': "Night watchman" state. (Not so close to anarchy, except consistent with strong sense of public order.)
 
  
::*'''Problems identified in Thought Monkey Youtube:'''  
+
::*Tissue growth/repair: largest component of tissue by dry weight.  75% of dry body weight.  
:::*No libertarian candidates on the national stage in two party state.
+
::*Water and pH balance; plasma proteins can exert osmotic pressure to help circulation of tissue fluids (I think this is the "interstitium", but I'm not completely sure).[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interstitium]
:::*No successful libertarian states.  No one's tried.  
+
::*Proteins can take up acids to contribute to blood Ph management.
:::*Monopolies, poverty. (We have extraordinarily high inequality right now.)
+
::*Metabolism, transport, immune system, energy systemWide range of functions hereWe have already met "lipproteins" that help carry fats aroundHere you learn that enzymes, transport agents, and hormones also have protein structures.
::::*Doesn’t solve conflicts bt “Rentier” and propertyless.  
+
::*Proteins also help make white blood cells, so support your immune system.   
::::*No guarantee that you won’t “bleed out in the street” for lack of healthcare.   
 
::::*Non-aggression principle unlikely in free marketMarkets can be quite aggressivePutting people out of their homes. Eviction. 
 
:::*Assumes increase in wealth produces increase in happiness (Easterlin paradox)
 
:::*Environmental concerns require collective action.   
 
  
:*'''Summing up:'''
+
:*'''Food Sources'''
:*(US conservative) Libertarianism: '''fundamental concern with human freedom understood as avoidance of coercion'''; minimal state; some morals legislation - often anti-abortion; no redistribution of income or wealthStrong concern with equality of liberty and avoidance of oppression, understood as forced labor.   
+
::*Complete proteins mostly from animal sources, including dairy, cheese. (Digress on the "complete protein controversy.  [https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6893534/]
 +
::*Soy is the only complete plant protein.
 +
::*Completing proteins, or, more current “protein scores”:  p. 52.  also compare links ceci beans [[https://tools.myfooddata.com/nutrition-facts/173757/100g/1]], lentils [https://tools.myfooddata.com/nutrition-facts/172421/100g/1], peanut butter  [[https://tools.myfooddata.com/nutrition-facts/174294/100g/1]].  Sirloin steak [https://tools.myfooddata.com/nutrition-facts/169457/100g/1].
 +
::*Advice on vegetarian diets - Mix grains and legumes, eat soy based foods like tofu if possibleNote reference to the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics document (in your links collection)
 +
::*Old Advice for plant proteins: Balance for "complete proteins". New Advice: Choose a variety of plant proteins over days. Consider "protein score", which is typically a combination of a PDCAAS (Protein digestivility Correted Amino Acid Score) [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protein_Digestibility_Corrected_Amino_Acid_Score#:~:text=Using%20the%20PDCAAS%20method%2C%20the,possible%20score%20being%20a%201.0.] and an Amino acid score [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amino_acid_score]   
 +
::*Note health benefits of vegetarian diet on p. 54.   
  
:*Basic intuition: '''Taxation (beyond minimal state functions) is a form of forced labor.''' Only legitimate for a narrow range of goals that we mutually benefit from, such as defense.
+
:*'''Digestion of Proteins'''
 +
::*Occurs in stomach and small intestines - unlike Carbs and Fats, which are not digested in stomach.
 +
::*Proteing enzymes have to be stored in inactive form (proenzymes or “precursors”) or they would break down body tisssue! 
  
:*(US Liberal) Libertarianism: Also focused on freedom, especially regarding respect for identity differences and private behaviors (favors decriminalization/legalization of drugs), but retains some of the original left-wing concerns of socialism::*Liberal Libertarianism has a '''more material interpretation of rights.'''
+
::*Overconsumption of protein by Americans, p. 59 Men at 181% of DRI, Women at 152%.
:::*Are you really free if you are living on the street? A conservative lib: Maybe, yes. A liberal lib: No!
 
:::*Are you really free if you are discriminated against?
 
::::*To be fair, conservative libertarians have responses to these challenges: Charity, persuasion, voluntary methods.
 
  
===Small Group Discussion===
+
:*'''Recommendations'''
 +
::*10-35% of calories from diet
 +
::*.8g / Kg of body weight.
 +
::*To meet essential amino acids, choose a variety of protein sources over days, not within a single meal. Do a ("personal protein tally" on your typical diet.)
 +
::*If necessary, check your "protein diet" with a blood test once in a while. [Prealbumin test [https://www.webmd.com/a-to-z-guides/what-is-a-prealbumin-test]
  
:*Whether you are liberal or conservative, do you place liberty and avoidance of coercion very high on your list of "really important values"? Or, could a case be made that it's the wrong "starting point"? Would "collectivism" be a more promising beginning?  How optimistic are you that a moral/political culture focused on liberty and freedom can resolve the problems associated with it?
+
::*Reasons not to consume excess amounts of proteins:
 +
:::*Often associated with high fat dietary sources
 +
:::*Crowds out other food sources
 +
:::*Kidneys work harder to get rid of nitrogen.  
 +
:::*Further reading: [https://www.healthline.com/health/too-much-protein Risks of too much protein]
 +
::*Debates about protein quality and quantity for athletes. [https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3905294/]
  
===Hibbing, Ch 6, Different Slates===
+
===Gordon Shepherd, ''Neurogastronomy'' C7 "Images of Smell"===
  
:*'''Introductory stuff'''
+
:C7Images of Smell
::*Story of Phineas Gage -- 1848 -- early example of biology and personality change.
 
::*Oliver Sachs work.
 
::*149: lobotomies.  
 
::*149: Lots of brain diffs are correlated to non-pathological conditions as well.  (mention reading and face recognition)
 
::*150: Some Parkinson's drugs can trigger behavioral changes like addictions and gambling. 
 
::*'''Could some brain diffs correlate with political orientation?'''
 
  
:*'''I Feel it in my Gut'''
+
:*The Olfactory Bulb: molecular and neural pathways at the bulbGlomerulus (glom) - convergence site of receptor cellsInterneuronsoften specialized processors.   Periglomeral cells, Mitral cells, tufted cellsGranule cells.   
::*Psychophysiology - the idea that we experience the world partly through our physiology. -- emotions as "action dispositions" -- '''we also trigger each other''' (escalation: story about ac and brother in law).
 
::*151: physiology of anger (it’s getting you ready to fight or flee), stress (digress on cortisol), polygraph - example of measuring autonomic functionsMention "'''negative partisanship'''" here.
 
::*151: how emotional states are instantiated in neural and physiological activity.  
 
::*CNS - central nervous system (head and spine) ANS - Autonomic Nervous system. Within ANS - SNS (sympathetic) "fight or flight" and PNS (parasympathetic) "rest and digest" activation reduces heart rate, sends blood to the gut.
 
::*153: from Hibbing's lab: patterns of activation are pretty stableSome people are agitated by dark rooms and loud noisesSame years later.
 
  
:*'''Politics on and in the Brain''' (two studies)
+
:*How does olfactory bulb represent smell?  Story of discovery: 1930s Edgar Adrian, hedgehogs, noticed how patterns of excitation could create an “image” of the smell, using electrophysiology techniques.
 +
:*Sokoloff method for tracking energy used by the brain with a marker for glucose uptake.  Important work that led to PET and fMRI.  Follows his own research from 70s in using this method to track energy use in the olfactory bulb as it is exposed to odors. 
 +
:*Confirms idea of a “smell image” or pattern of activation in the glomeruli. Started to fill in a “map” of the receptor sites on the bulb.  1990s. 
 +
:*Some “odor images” from the work of Michael Leon and Brett Johnson. [https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4075437/]
 +
:*Final point: The olfactory pathways are heavily modulated - sensitive to behavioral state: appetite, aversion, openness to experience, all affect flavor perception.
  
::*'''Kanai and Rees MRI study''' -- looking at ACC (anterior cingulate cortex) and amygdala of test subject in an MRI.  ACC activated by tasks involving error detection and conflict resolution -- results on 156:  found correlation between liberalism and size of ACC.  Bigger.  However, as for the amygdala (which is involved in face recog and emotion regulation), conservatives have bigger amygdalas (156: more active in face recognition and threat detection (also C5) .  (Mention history of mask wearing and conservatism.)
 
::*'''Note these correlations increase by degree of partisanship.
 
'''
 
::*Note connection to BeanFest. 
 
  
::*157: caution in reading these results.  Still, you can predict political orientation from brain differences.
+
===Personal Protein Tally===
  
::*'''Amodio 2007''': Specific brain wave amplitude diff that varied by pol. orientation.  Basically, liberals have strong ACC activity spikes in response to error detection in the go/no go task.   
+
:*We've used a "profile" metaphor to talk about carbs and fats (profiles of complexity in carbs and fat saturation for fats), but with proteins, it makes sense to "tally" or add up your intake, while watching for protein quality.   
  
::*Back to Kain and Rees research: bigger amygdalas of conservatives help with (or effect of?) face recognitionThreat detection. (Fits with the attentional studies of Chap 5)(Try to find some empathy for conservatives who don't like masks!)
+
:*Calculate your protein goal in grams150 lbs. = 68kg x .8 = 54grams RDI /day
 +
:*Go through your diet and look at the amounts of good protein in your day'''How hard is it to meet your goal?'''
 +
{| class="wikitable"
 +
|-
 +
! Food
 +
! Protein Value
 +
|-
 +
| '''Breakfast'''
 +
|
 +
|-
 +
| Egg/toast/butter
 +
| 11
 +
|-
 +
| '''Midmorning'''
 +
|
 +
|-
 +
| Muffin
 +
| 6
 +
|-
 +
| '''Lunch'''
 +
|
 +
|-
 +
| Ceci/fruit/yogurt
 +
| 14
 +
|-
 +
| Appetizers - cheese/crackers
 +
| 11
 +
|-
 +
| '''Dinner Options'''
 +
|
 +
|-
 +
| Lentils & Rice
 +
| 12
 +
|-
 +
| Lentil Soup
 +
| 15
 +
|-
 +
| Black Beans & Rice
 +
| 23
 +
|-
 +
| Tuscan Bean Soup
 +
| 10
 +
|-
 +
| Pasta (125g)
 +
| 18
 +
|-
 +
| Tuna
 +
| 19
 +
|-
 +
| Salmon (8oz)
 +
| 45
 +
|-
 +
| Tofu (1/2 cup)
 +
| 10
  
:*'''Politics Makes Me Sweat'''
+
|}
 
 
::*EDA studies -- electrodermal activity -- skin conductivity, especially as it varies with sweat.  Simple way of measuring SNS activity.  SNS activity also triggers focused attention.  Largely unconscious (study). 
 
::*Study from Hibbing in 2008 (161): EDA activity correlated to policy positions on "socially protective policies" (those involving a threat).  "People more physiologically responsive to threat stimuli (images) were more likely to support policies aimed at reducing or addressing threats to the social status quo" 161. The more conservative the more sweat.
 
 
 
::*2nd Hibbing lab study: Known that conservatives have strong triggers for disgust/impurity.  Sexual issues in politics, for example, not taxes. Note sig: not a general skin response to policies you favor, only a cluster. (We will be covering this in Haidt soon.) 162: more on disgust -- nature's way of helping us avoid things (but not perfect).
 
 
 
::*EDA disgust studies line up with fart spray studies.  Morality and smell are connected. 
 
::*Hibbing EDA study 163: disaggregate data and its the sex-issues driving the SNS response. 
 
::*EDA studies have shown increase activity around inter-racial interactions.  Note: resisting preferential race policy needn't be racist, could be based on strong value on equal treatment.  But it could be racist.  Very hard to tell the diff in surveys since open racism isn't cool.     
 
::*Practical issue: studies showing unconscious response to group affiliation. SNS activates in presence of politically relevant out-groups.  It could be that conservative vs. liberal racists are having different physiological reactions to out groups.
 
 
 
::*French study on response to out-groups. 165 Verbal reports non-racist, but EDA showed activation for non-white image. (Our bodies can betray us.) (Unconscious racism?  At least unconscious activation of potential threat.)
 
 
 
::*Emory study 165 - application bias study.  Test subjects with higher SNS activation show greater preference for white applicants.
 
 
 
:*In Your Face Politics
 
 
 
::*Studies assessing our ability to determine political orientation from faces (not including hair or dress!).  Proxies for this judgement could include "emotional expressivity" (168), which Liberals score higher on in "Berkeley Expressivity Questionaire". 
 
 
 
::*'''Your face is communicating, pretty much all the time.....''' "the visual Twitter accounts of our nervous system"167  Not just communicating emotion, but group membership.
 
 
 
::*Looking for physiological markers of facial signaling or pol. orientation.  Drawing on Berkeley Expressivity Questionnaire (validated instrument correlating expressivity and liberalism).  (Note that this fact pattern would explain ability to recognize group affiliation.)
 
 
 
::*Hibbing study involving the facial muscle ''corrugator supercilii" (the eybrow furrowing muscle).  Females of all pol. orientations more expressive than males.  Liberal males about as expressive as females.  (Apologies to macho liberal guys!)  Conservative males were distinctive for lack of emotional expressivity.
 
 
 
===Small Group Discussion on Physio-politics / Neuropolitics===
 
 
 
:*Practical Problem: How should physio-politics affect our conversation practices in moral and political discussion and experience?  What are the lessons?  What values should we adopt?
 
 
 
:*If "physio-politics" is real, then we're all having somewhat different physiological reactions to news, issues, and each other.
 
:*If the "social epistemology" hypothesis from Haidt is true, then we are "smarter together" and we need to make use of our differences.
 
 
 
====Practical advice for better political and moral discussion in light of physio-politics====
 
 
 
:*List goes here
 
:*1. Model exploratory thought. (How do you do that, specifically?)
 
:*2. Avoid escalation of physiological responses. (How do you do that, specifically?)
 
:*Acknowledge insight across the spectrum.
 
:*Cultivate diverse relationships if possible.
 
:*Avoid perjorative lables.
 
:*Views can chage even if orientations don't.
 
:*Accept difference that won't change, focus on pragmatics and cooperation.
 
:*Humor, if possible.  Self-effacing first.
 
:*Acknowledge physio-politics in the discussion.
 
:*Don't "sugar coat" differences.  (Be true to yourself.)
 

Latest revision as of 19:09, 10 February 2025

7. FEB 10

Assigned Work

  • Nix, Stacy. Chapter 4: "Proteins" Williams' Basic Nutrition and Diet Therapy (pp. 47-63).
  • Shepard, Gordon, C7 "Images of Smell: An "Aha" Moment" (66-76; 10)
  • Fill out Proteins Worksheet (Points)

In-class

  • Energy density v. Nutrient density.

Nix, "Proteins"

  • Nature of
  • 20 amino acids, 9 essential; proteins are polypeptides -- chains of amino acids 100s of links long. Proteins exist in specific forms in foods (ex. casein is milk protein) and are broken down by us into amino acids and resembled as protein in metabolism.
  • Classes of amino acids: indispensable (9), dispensable (5), and conditionally indispensable (6).
  • Conditionally dispensable: Example: If low on Mthionine(essential), then you need cysteine (cond. indis.) from diet.
  • About 16% nitrogen; protein is a primary source of nitrogen in diet.
  • Catabolism and Anabolism: Metabolic process of breaking down tissue and building it up.
  • Nitrogen Balance is shown when excretion of urinary nitrogen occurs as by product of protein metabolism (ratio of 1 g of urinary nitrogen to 6.25 g of protein). Negative nitrogen balance can be a symptom of protein deficiency. Kwashiorkor.
  • Tissue proteins, plasma proteins, and dietary protein. You dietary protein is contributing to a much larger and complex protein manufacture and delivery service.
  • Functions of Protein Metabolism
  • Tissue growth/repair: largest component of tissue by dry weight. 75% of dry body weight.
  • Water and pH balance; plasma proteins can exert osmotic pressure to help circulation of tissue fluids (I think this is the "interstitium", but I'm not completely sure).[1]
  • Proteins can take up acids to contribute to blood Ph management.
  • Metabolism, transport, immune system, energy system. Wide range of functions here. We have already met "lipproteins" that help carry fats around. Here you learn that enzymes, transport agents, and hormones also have protein structures.
  • Proteins also help make white blood cells, so support your immune system.
  • Food Sources
  • Complete proteins mostly from animal sources, including dairy, cheese. (Digress on the "complete protein controversy. [2]
  • Soy is the only complete plant protein.
  • Completing proteins, or, more current “protein scores”: p. 52. also compare links ceci beans [[3]], lentils [4], peanut butter [[5]]. Sirloin steak [6].
  • Advice on vegetarian diets - Mix grains and legumes, eat soy based foods like tofu if possible. Note reference to the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics document (in your links collection)
  • Old Advice for plant proteins: Balance for "complete proteins". New Advice: Choose a variety of plant proteins over days. Consider "protein score", which is typically a combination of a PDCAAS (Protein digestivility Correted Amino Acid Score) [7] and an Amino acid score [8]
  • Note health benefits of vegetarian diet on p. 54.
  • Digestion of Proteins
  • Occurs in stomach and small intestines - unlike Carbs and Fats, which are not digested in stomach.
  • Proteing enzymes have to be stored in inactive form (proenzymes or “precursors”) or they would break down body tisssue!
  • Overconsumption of protein by Americans, p. 59 Men at 181% of DRI, Women at 152%.
  • Recommendations
  • 10-35% of calories from diet
  • .8g / Kg of body weight.
  • To meet essential amino acids, choose a variety of protein sources over days, not within a single meal. Do a ("personal protein tally" on your typical diet.)
  • If necessary, check your "protein diet" with a blood test once in a while. [Prealbumin test [9]
  • Reasons not to consume excess amounts of proteins:
  • Often associated with high fat dietary sources
  • Crowds out other food sources
  • Kidneys work harder to get rid of nitrogen.
  • Further reading: Risks of too much protein
  • Debates about protein quality and quantity for athletes. [10]

Gordon Shepherd, Neurogastronomy C7 "Images of Smell"

C7: Images of Smell
  • The Olfactory Bulb: molecular and neural pathways at the bulb. Glomerulus (glom) - convergence site of receptor cells. Interneurons: often specialized processors. Periglomeral cells, Mitral cells, tufted cells. Granule cells.
  • How does olfactory bulb represent smell? Story of discovery: 1930s Edgar Adrian, hedgehogs, noticed how patterns of excitation could create an “image” of the smell, using electrophysiology techniques.
  • Sokoloff method for tracking energy used by the brain with a marker for glucose uptake. Important work that led to PET and fMRI. Follows his own research from 70s in using this method to track energy use in the olfactory bulb as it is exposed to odors.
  • Confirms idea of a “smell image” or pattern of activation in the glomeruli. Started to fill in a “map” of the receptor sites on the bulb. 1990s.
  • Some “odor images” from the work of Michael Leon and Brett Johnson. [11]
  • Final point: The olfactory pathways are heavily modulated - sensitive to behavioral state: appetite, aversion, openness to experience, all affect flavor perception.


Personal Protein Tally

  • We've used a "profile" metaphor to talk about carbs and fats (profiles of complexity in carbs and fat saturation for fats), but with proteins, it makes sense to "tally" or add up your intake, while watching for protein quality.
  • Calculate your protein goal in grams. 150 lbs. = 68kg x .8 = 54grams RDI /day
  • Go through your diet and look at the amounts of good protein in your day. How hard is it to meet your goal?
Food Protein Value
Breakfast
Egg/toast/butter 11
Midmorning
Muffin 6
Lunch
Ceci/fruit/yogurt 14
Appetizers - cheese/crackers 11
Dinner Options
Lentils & Rice 12
Lentil Soup 15
Black Beans & Rice 23
Tuscan Bean Soup 10
Pasta (125g) 18
Tuna 19
Salmon (8oz) 45
Tofu (1/2 cup) 10