Difference between revisions of "Philosophy of Food"

From Alfino
Jump to: navigation, search
m (Other Resources)
m (Main Course Information)
(13 intermediate revisions by one user not shown)
Line 10: Line 10:
 
:*[[Philosophy of Food Reading Schedule Spring 2019]]
 
:*[[Philosophy of Food Reading Schedule Spring 2019]]
 
:*[[Philosophy of Food Class Notes Spring 2019]]
 
:*[[Philosophy of Food Class Notes Spring 2019]]
:*[https://gonzagau-my.sharepoint.com/:f:/g/personal/alfino_gonzaga_edu/EgeQPIC33QBPr3qJLh12C5UBeg_Jl8njRP2TUDRGXmxdwg?e=39NRHZ Sharepoint site]
+
:*[https://gonzagau-my.sharepoint.com/:f:/g/personal/alfino_gonzaga_edu/EgeQPIC33QBPr3qJLh12C5UBeg_Jl8njRP2TUDRGXmxdwg?e=39NRHZ Current Sharepoint site]
 +
 
 +
 
 +
:*[https://gonzagau.sharepoint.com/sites/faculty/alfino/food New Sharepoint Site -- Still Testing and setting up.]
  
 
====Advice, About the course, Method, Wiki edits====
 
====Advice, About the course, Method, Wiki edits====
Line 16: Line 19:
 
:*[[Philosophy of Food Course Research Questions]]
 
:*[[Philosophy of Food Course Research Questions]]
 
:*[[Basic Course Information for Philosophy of Food]]
 
:*[[Basic Course Information for Philosophy of Food]]
 +
:*[[Philosophy of Food Course Core Course Proposal]]
 
:*[[Philosophical Methods]]
 
:*[[Philosophical Methods]]
 
:*[[Advice on Reading]]
 
:*[[Advice on Reading]]
Line 22: Line 26:
 
:*[[Student Practice Page]]
 
:*[[Student Practice Page]]
  
 
+
==Forms and Worksheets==
==Forms==
+
  
 
*[https://goo.gl/forms/0niZBty8711bPpq63 Roster Information]
 
*[https://goo.gl/forms/0niZBty8711bPpq63 Roster Information]
Line 37: Line 40:
 
::*[[Vitamins]]
 
::*[[Vitamins]]
  
==Final Paper Options==
+
==Outline of Some Philosophy of Food Assignments and Topic Ideas==
  
:*Your final paper should be a 7-9 page (typed double spaced) paper satisfying one of the following topics:
+
:*'''Practicum: Diet Review and Improvement''' -- Review your own diet and consider the effects of specific changes you might make. This assignment is optional, but you must do either this one or the "Food Investigation" paper.
::*1.  "My Philosophy of Food" -- Put together your best answers to the most basic questions that define a philosophy of food.  What are the fundamental features of a sound approach to food?  How should we think about food, the Western Diet, and the satisfactions that food makes possible?  What are the implications for your developed philosophy of food in terms of food choices and personal food culture (roughly what to eat and how to eat).
+
::*2.  Research Paper -- Food topics abound.  Chose something that builds on your disciplinary expertise or not.  You may choose an fact-based topic, but you may also want to consider topics that integrate ethical and public policy issues and the food system.
+
  
:*First StepsIn early April, I'll ask you to share some ideas about your topic interests in small group work.
+
::*Choose from the following options. Depending upon your current understanding of nutrition and your own diet, you may want to combine Diet Review and Diet Improvement.  
  
==Ideas for Food Journaling and Investigations in Florence and Beyond==
+
::*'''Diet Review'''
  
Here are some ideas for optional work that helps you connect our Philosophy of Food course to Florence and your study abroad experienceMany of these involve an kind of amateur "ethnography" in which you carefully observe characteristics of the local (or European) food culture for distinctive practices and organization.
+
:::*'''Tracking and Comparision to Dietary Guidelines.''' Use an online diet tracking site to create a "baseline" analysis of your diet. Compare your diet to US Dietary Guidelines [https://health.gov/dietaryguidelines/] which we will read in the course.  Consider Myfitnesspal or any food/diet site that is connected to the large food and nutrition databasesEnter most of the foods you eat over a 7-10 day period.  We will get into more detail on this, but try to look up nutritional norms for your age, health, and weight.  Compare with your actual diet and the US Dietary Guidelines.  Write up your observations in a 3-4 paper.  You may want to focus on a general comparison of your diet to the guidelines, things you didn't notice or were surprised by about your diet, the proportion of whole food vs. industrial food products, the regularity or lack of regularity in the diet, etc.  I recommend that you make tracking a part of your practicum, but, depending upon your current knowledge of your diet, you may be able to do some tracking and also incorporate one or two of the Diet Improvement ideas.
  
:*Restaurant and Food markets (including supermarket) culture
+
::*'''Diet Improvement'''
  
::*Visit several supermarkets and at least one open market (Mercato Centrale, but maybe also the [https://www.tripadvisor.com/Attraction_Review-g187895-d195019-Reviews-Mercato_di_Sant_Ambrogio-Florence_Tuscany.html Mercato St. Ambrogio], including at least one outside the centro.  Observe the layout of the market, proportions of different kinds of products (industrial, artiginale, local, national brands), notice how food is presented and served to be soldIf you are quantitatively oriented you might focus on the sizes and prices of foods in comparison to the US. Qualitatively issues include the aesthetics of the market, quality of products, similarities and differences about the products offered, and how the market is organized. Who is shopping there and what are they buying?  What can you tell about the "sourcing" of the foods? Try an [https://www.promoqui.it/firenze/volantino/esselunga-via-masaccio Esselunga] or Coop ([https://www.coopfirenze.it/punti-vendita/firenze-via-cimabue via Gioberti] or [https://www.coopfirenze.it/punti-vendita/firenze-via-forlanini Novoli] #22 bus from the station)Don't just visit small supermarkets in the center. You can also make comparative observations between Italian food culture and other places in Europe that you visit.
+
:::*'''Eliminations.'''Try small changes in your diet by eliminating some or all of the following: industrial processed food, sodas, eating between meals, and refined carbohydrates, especially refined sugarConsider re-sourcing industrial meat to local organic. Try adding a non-meat protein dinner, such as a lentil or bean dish.  Try the same as a restaurantUse a journal to track your experience of these changes.  Using the journal as a source, report on your experience in a 3-4 page reflection paper.  
  
::*Since you visit restaurants to complete your diet here, try to develop a sense of the variety of Italian eating establishments. Get outside the Viale for this assignment as well.  Compare menu organization, content, assumptions about diner preferencesHow do Italians eat out? When do they go to dinner?  How to they take apperitivi?  You may need to research the different types of restaurants to understand your experience.   
+
:::*'''Elimination-Replacement Diets.''' Some eliminations do not require replacements, but others doIf you eat alot of industrial food and your goal is to reduce that significantly, then you will need "replacements" for the lost mealsMaybe you will try to ditch that sugary breakfast cereal, decrease meat consumption, or
  
:*Street Food, Cafes and coffee culture, gelato, and specialty food stores
+
:::*'''Diet Enrichment.''' Another kind of diet improvement goal you could have for the practicum is to find three new meals that you can make and add to your dinner routine.  These new meals can meet a variety of goals, including some that emerge from your diet tracking and review.  For example, you might try to acquire new non-industrial, low-meat/no-meat, microbiota friendly meals!
  
::*Florence has some distinctive street foods.  Read about [https://www.visitflorence.com/eating-and-drinking-in-florence/florence-street-food.html Tripa and Lampradotta] and, if you are brave, go find some and try it.
 
::*Read about how Italians take their coffee, learn how to order coffee and pastries and then sample a variety of cafes from the fancy places in and just off Piazza Repubblica ([https://it.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caff%C3%A8_Gilli Gigli], [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caff%C3%A8_Giubbe_Rosse Giubbe Rosso], or the [http://www.lostinflorence.it/wine/articles/caffe-giacosa Giacosa], which is frequented more by Florentines.  Go to some modest local cafes.  What's different about them from the fancy ones?
 
::*Specialty stores with unique assortments of Italian foods can be found all over Florence.  I'll start making a list, but again, you should sample some inside and outside the centro.  For example, in my neighborhood there is a specialty shop for [https://www.tripadvisor.it/LocationPhotoDirectLink-g187895-d6351758-i227462520-Panificio_Maddaloni_di_Maddaloni_Gennaro-Florence_Tuscany.html Mozzarella di Bufala].  Outside the viale you can still find butcher shops and small shops that sell fruit and vegetables. Learn about vino sfuso.
 
  
These experiences can be processed for the course as journal assignments (3 or 6 for 5% or 10% of your grade) or short research papers.  You should take a notebook or other device for writing down observations.  Your journals should synthesis your observations rather than present raw data. Record both things you observe and think you understand as well as things that are puzzling to you. Research some the puzzles. Often this requires finding Italians who can be "informants" or you. Please pick a few highlights to share with the class.
 
  
==Rough Outline of Optional Philosophy of Food Assignments and Topic Ideas==
+
:*'''Practicum: Food Investigation Paper''' - a short 3-4 page paper in which you investigate a food issue and report briefly to the class about it.  This is an optional assignment but you must do either this assignment or the Diet Review Practicum.
  
I will work on some new assignments for the Florence version of the courseSome of the assignments listed below may not be practical under conditions in Florence:
+
::*The Food Investigation Paper can involve any Food Studies topic of your choice, but ideally, it should related to a question or curiosity you have, even about your immediate food environmentSo some of the suggestions below for the Food System Research topics.  You may also want to choose a topic that relates your major to Food Studies.
  
:*'''Diet Review and Improvement''' -- Review your own diet and consider the effects of specific changes you might make.
+
:*'''Food System Research''' -- Systems, Journalism, & Activism -- Research a specific aspect of food production and distribution in your local food system.  A research focus involves documenting the issue and giving your analysis of it, whereas an activism focus may involve trying to promote positive change.  Here are a few examples:  
 
+
::*Choose 1, 2, or all three of these options:
+
:::*1. '''Tracking.''' Use an online diet tracking site to create a "baseline" analysis of your diet. Compare your diet to US Dietary Guidelines [https://health.gov/dietaryguidelines/].  You can start this assignment between Feb 1 and March 1.  Consider Myfitnesspal or any food/diet site that is connected to the large food and nutrition databases.  Enter most of the foods you eat over a 7-10 day period.  We will get into more detail on this, but try to look up nutritional norms for your age, health, and weight.  Compare with your actual diet and the US Dietary Guidelines.  Write up your observations in a 3-4 paper.  You may want to focus on a general comparison of your diet to the guidelines, things you didn't notice or were surprised by about your diet, the proportion of whole food vs. industrial food products, the regularity or lack of regularity in the diet, etc.  Due no later than March 1. 
+
:::*2. '''Elimination Diet.'''Try small changes in your diet by eliminating some or all of the following: industrial processed food, sodas, eating between meals, and refined carbohydrates, especially refined sugar.  Consider re-sourcing industrial meat to local organic. Try adding a non-meat protein dinner, such as a lentil or bean dish.  Try the same as a restaurant.  Use a journal to track your experience of these changes.  Using the journal as a source, report on your experience in a 2-3 reflection paper. Start as soon as mid-February but finish no later than late March.
+
:::*3. '''3 Way Diet analysis.'''In light of your study of nutrition this semester, make an analysis of your diet that considers three standards: nutrition, satisfaction, and practicality. Late April.
+
 
+
:*'''Food System Research, Food Journalism, & Food Activism''' -- Research a specific aspect of food production and distribution in your local food system.  A research focus involves documenting the issue and giving your analysis of it, whereas an activism focus may involve trying to promote positive change.  Here are a few examples:  
+
  
 
:::*Research a particular grocery store's sourcing choices.
 
:::*Research a particular grocery store's sourcing choices.
Line 104: Line 94:
 
::*Research a fad diet from the last few years in light of research and reflection.
 
::*Research a fad diet from the last few years in light of research and reflection.
 
::*Are we getting better at farm raised fish?
 
::*Are we getting better at farm raised fish?
 +
 +
==Final Paper Options==
 +
 +
:*Your final paper should be a 7-9 page (typed double spaced) paper satisfying one of the following topics:
 +
::*1.  "My Philosophy of Food" -- Put together your best answers to the most basic questions that define a philosophy of food.  What are the fundamental features of a sound approach to food?  How should we think about food, the Western Diet, and the satisfactions that food makes possible?  What are the implications for your developed philosophy of food in terms of food choices and personal food culture (roughly what to eat and how to eat).
 +
::*2.  Research Paper -- Food topics abound.  Chose something that builds on your disciplinary expertise or not.  You may choose an fact-based topic, but you may also want to consider topics that integrate ethical and public policy issues and the food system. 
 +
 +
:*First Steps:  In early April, I'll ask you to share some ideas about your topic interests in small group work.
  
 
==Previously posted Course Resources==
 
==Previously posted Course Resources==
  
 
:*[[Food movies]] - a list of current food movies.  Please help update it!
 
:*[[Food movies]] - a list of current food movies.  Please help update it!
 
  
 
:*[[2017Philosophy_of_Food_Reading_Schedule]]
 
:*[[2017Philosophy_of_Food_Reading_Schedule]]
Line 115: Line 112:
 
:*[[Philosophy of Food Fall 2018 Class Notes]] Florence
 
:*[[Philosophy of Food Fall 2018 Class Notes]] Florence
  
===Miscellaneous Food News and Food Culture===
+
====Miscellaneous Food News and Food Culture====
  
 
:*Electric Spoon [[http://www.foxnews.com/leisure/2016/10/18/electric-spoon-could-make-veggies-taste-like-chocolate-or-cheeseburgers/]]
 
:*Electric Spoon [[http://www.foxnews.com/leisure/2016/10/18/electric-spoon-could-make-veggies-taste-like-chocolate-or-cheeseburgers/]]

Revision as of 14:29, 14 February 2019

Main Course Information

Schedule & Notes


Advice, About the course, Method, Wiki edits

Forms and Worksheets

  • Worksheets for Nutrition Chapters

Outline of Some Philosophy of Food Assignments and Topic Ideas

  • Practicum: Diet Review and Improvement -- Review your own diet and consider the effects of specific changes you might make. This assignment is optional, but you must do either this one or the "Food Investigation" paper.
  • Choose from the following options. Depending upon your current understanding of nutrition and your own diet, you may want to combine Diet Review and Diet Improvement.
  • Diet Review
  • Tracking and Comparision to Dietary Guidelines. Use an online diet tracking site to create a "baseline" analysis of your diet. Compare your diet to US Dietary Guidelines [1] which we will read in the course. Consider Myfitnesspal or any food/diet site that is connected to the large food and nutrition databases. Enter most of the foods you eat over a 7-10 day period. We will get into more detail on this, but try to look up nutritional norms for your age, health, and weight. Compare with your actual diet and the US Dietary Guidelines. Write up your observations in a 3-4 paper. You may want to focus on a general comparison of your diet to the guidelines, things you didn't notice or were surprised by about your diet, the proportion of whole food vs. industrial food products, the regularity or lack of regularity in the diet, etc. I recommend that you make tracking a part of your practicum, but, depending upon your current knowledge of your diet, you may be able to do some tracking and also incorporate one or two of the Diet Improvement ideas.
  • Diet Improvement
  • Eliminations.Try small changes in your diet by eliminating some or all of the following: industrial processed food, sodas, eating between meals, and refined carbohydrates, especially refined sugar. Consider re-sourcing industrial meat to local organic. Try adding a non-meat protein dinner, such as a lentil or bean dish. Try the same as a restaurant. Use a journal to track your experience of these changes. Using the journal as a source, report on your experience in a 3-4 page reflection paper.
  • Elimination-Replacement Diets. Some eliminations do not require replacements, but others do. If you eat alot of industrial food and your goal is to reduce that significantly, then you will need "replacements" for the lost meals. Maybe you will try to ditch that sugary breakfast cereal, decrease meat consumption, or
  • Diet Enrichment. Another kind of diet improvement goal you could have for the practicum is to find three new meals that you can make and add to your dinner routine. These new meals can meet a variety of goals, including some that emerge from your diet tracking and review. For example, you might try to acquire new non-industrial, low-meat/no-meat, microbiota friendly meals!


  • Practicum: Food Investigation Paper - a short 3-4 page paper in which you investigate a food issue and report briefly to the class about it. This is an optional assignment but you must do either this assignment or the Diet Review Practicum.
  • The Food Investigation Paper can involve any Food Studies topic of your choice, but ideally, it should related to a question or curiosity you have, even about your immediate food environment. So some of the suggestions below for the Food System Research topics. You may also want to choose a topic that relates your major to Food Studies.
  • Food System Research -- Systems, Journalism, & Activism -- Research a specific aspect of food production and distribution in your local food system. A research focus involves documenting the issue and giving your analysis of it, whereas an activism focus may involve trying to promote positive change. Here are a few examples:
  • Research a particular grocery store's sourcing choices.
  • Why does a local store sell peppers from Holland? Can they be sourced locally?
  • What organizations exist in Spokane to help promote local food production?
  • Investigate Sodexho's dietary standards and sourcing choices?
  • Take a favorite food product, food, or meal in your life and investigate or compare sourcing options. This could involved documenting the sources of a food product, making a dish from differently sourced ingredients, or other possibilities.
  • Visit a local supplier of organic foods or a local producer of industrial foods. Integrate relevant course issues into your analysis and reflection on your visit.
  • Visit Pure Eiyre Dairy in Othello, which touts its humane and organic methods. Sample their products, comparing them to industrial equivalents. http://www.pureeiredairy.com .
  • Try to visit Snyder's bread factory and then one of the artisan bakers in town: Common Crumb, Luna (Boosie's), Petite Chat.
  • Assess one or more restaurant menus in terms of nutrition, sourcing, or gastronomy.
  • Visit a local organic ranch or farm to gain insight into their values and challenges. What are the economics of such an enterprise.
  • Food security topic -- Learn about the food distribution systems that supply food banks, community food pantries, and free meals. Where does the food come from? Who uses or depends upon this food system? How well does it work to provide food security?
  • Food movie and book groups -- Get together with other students or work on your own to deepen your understanding of an additional book or movie source on food. Choose journals and/or class reporting as part of this assignment. Food movies
  • Some possible books:
  • Catching Fire Richard Wrangham -- This book by a leading medical anthropologist has been widely discussed and referenced in the last year. It brings together a fascinating literature on the effects of cooking on human evolution.
  • The Good Gut Justin and Erica Sonnenburg -- This microbiology couple at Stanford contributed this volume to the current discussion gut bacterial" or your microbiome.
  • Mindful Eating Jan Chozen Bays -- In this work, the author, a medical doctor, explores the ways that becoming a more mindful eater can improve your awareness of the importance of eating, your diet, control of appetite, and enjoyment of food.
  • In Meat We Trust Maureen Ogle -- Historians will like this story of the US cultural and dietary relationship with meat.
  • Philosophers at Table Raymond Boisvert and Lisa Heldke -- A recent work in philosophy on the nature of food and being human.
  • More Than a Meal: The Turkey in History, Myth, Rituah and Reality.Karen Davis, (New York: Lantern Books, 2001)
  • Caffeinated Murray Carpenter
  • Short Term Research - Many of the issues and topics we discuss are in flux due to emerging research and changes in food production and consumption. Here are some suggested topics for further research.
  • What are the alternatives to "culling" of male layers or treatment of male calves at dairy operations?
  • Can we breed animals "back" to conditions prior to the distorted breeding programs of industrial agriculture?
  • Food ethnography: Study a food or food system from your ethnic, regional, or class identity. The specific goal of the study will depend upon your interests. You might want to explore a food from your family life or make a critical study of the disruption of a food culture.
  • Research a fad diet from the last few years in light of research and reflection.
  • Are we getting better at farm raised fish?

Final Paper Options

  • Your final paper should be a 7-9 page (typed double spaced) paper satisfying one of the following topics:
  • 1. "My Philosophy of Food" -- Put together your best answers to the most basic questions that define a philosophy of food. What are the fundamental features of a sound approach to food? How should we think about food, the Western Diet, and the satisfactions that food makes possible? What are the implications for your developed philosophy of food in terms of food choices and personal food culture (roughly what to eat and how to eat).
  • 2. Research Paper -- Food topics abound. Chose something that builds on your disciplinary expertise or not. You may choose an fact-based topic, but you may also want to consider topics that integrate ethical and public policy issues and the food system.
  • First Steps: In early April, I'll ask you to share some ideas about your topic interests in small group work.

Previously posted Course Resources

  • Food movies - a list of current food movies. Please help update it!

Miscellaneous Food News and Food Culture

  • Electric Spoon [[2]]
  • Fasting -- Mark Mattson: Why fasting bolsters brain power. [3]
  • Weird food songs (good for food and gender reflection):
  • The Newbeats, "Bread and Butter" 1964 [4]
  • Nancy Walker, "I Can Cook, Too!" [5]
  • Jared Diamond, The World Until Yesterday, note on gluttony (see links)