2009 Fall Proseminar Class Notes

I will post some notes on our readings to this page and I invite you to contribute text, questions, and comments about the issues under discussion. You can either enter text or links directly into the Class notes page or use the "discussion" tab, which is also set up by class date.

Alfino 15:16, 6 September 2009 (UTC)

Return to Philosophy Proseminar

9/1

This was our introductory class. We made introductions, went over the course goals, the course website, and wiki. We brought up a wide range of topics for use in class.

9/22

Dennett's general argument in Ch. 2:

IC/P. Darwin's theory of natural selection establishes a process by which variation and species can be explained as a result of incremental change.

IC/P. The features of the process of natural selection are also the features of algorithms (substrate neutrality, mindlessness, guaranteed results).

C. Natural selection may an instance of a broader algorithmic process which explains the emergence of order in natural systems.

Dennett's general argument in Ch. 3:

The following claims are argued for, but also occur as premises in the larger argument of the book.

IC/P. Darwin's algorithm allows for explanations of order without reference to telos.

IC/P. Explanations of order without reference to telos undermine traditional views of the role of mind in order.

IC/P. The algorithm of selection can be thought of as operating within a "design space." A good trick, such as "reinforcement learning" may give an organism a way of creating order in its phenotype, not just accumulating design in its genotype.

IC/P. Using the algorithm of selection in this way involves an acceptable reduction.

Alfino 17:14, 22 September 2009 (UTC)